Classic Cheesecakes

Rich Original Vanilla – It all starts here! An authentic New York Style cheesecake, crafted with Kraft Philadelphia cream cheese, farm fresh eggs, a touch of sugar, heavy cream, and our custom blended pure vanilla extract. Add a dusting of crust, and the result… An amazingly creamy, velvety smooth, simply unforgettable cheesecake. Some refer to it as "plain" … but we think you'll agree… there's nothing "plain" about it! This friends, is the foundation of all of our cheesecakes!

We have a wide variety of cheesecakes available in our store at any time. Please call ahead if you would like to ensure availability of a particular size and flavor.


  • Marble – Rich chocolate cheesecake swirled into our Original Vanilla.
  • Raspberry Swirl – Real raspberries swirled through the Original Vanilla.
  • Chocolate Raspberry Swirl – The perfect combination of the Marble and Raspberry Swirl.
  • White Chocolate Raspberry Swirl – White chocolate cheesecake and raspberries swirled into the Original Vanilla.
  • Strawberry Swirl – Real strawberries swirled through the Original Vanilla.
  • Very Berry Swirl – A blend of real blueberries and raspberries swirled into the Original Vanilla.
  • Blueberry Swirl – Only blueberries swirled through the Original Vanilla.
  • Pumpkin Swirl(Seasonal - Fall/Winter) Subtly seasoned pumpkin swirled into the Original Vanilla (a fall and Christmas favorite)! For those who really love the taste of pumpkin, see our Pumpkin Cheesecake in our "Blended" cakes below.
  • Caramel Swirl – Rich Original Vanilla with a swirl of sweet, creamy caramel.


  • Mango (Seasonal - Summer) Pieces of fresh mango blended throughout.
  • Pineapple – (Seasonal - Summer) Delicate chunks of pineapple throughout.
  • Mandarin Orange(Seasonal - Summer) Mandarin orange slices folded in!
  • Oreo – Chocolate cookies with cream blended through. This cake uses the same cookie crumbs as a crust.
  • Chocolate Chip – Rich Original Vanilla with first-class chocolate shaved into the cake.
  • Pumpkin(Seasonal - Fall/Winter) Our Original Cheesecake with lots of Pumpkin flavor. It is a rich & wonderful marriage!


    • Key Lime – One of our more "sassy" flavors, be ready for a taste of sweet key lime in every bite!
    • Lemon(Seasonal- Spring) NOW AVAILABLE   A delicate flavoring of lemon; refreshing, not pucker-producing!
    • Coconut Cream – A masterful combination of coconut and creamy cheesecake. A coconut lover's delight!
    • Kahlua – Delightful all year round. This one gives new meaning to Kahlua & Cream!
    • Chocolate – Rich creamy cheesecake crafted with a premium chocolate! (For an extra deep chocolate experience, try our Chocolate Chocolate Chip!)
    • Amaretto – A hint of almond flows through this classic.
    • Chocolate Amaretto – The blending of our Chocolate and Amaretto cheesecakes!
    • Raspberry Amaretto – Our Amaretto cheesecake with real raspberries swirled in.
    • Chocolate Baileys Irish Cream(Seasonal- Winter) Chocolate cheesecake, with a rich coffee extract and Baileys Irish Cream liquor.
    • Eggnog - (Seasonal - Winter) - A must have for eggnog lover's!  Creamy eggnog cheesecake...need we say more??

Classic Line Sizes, Servings, Prices:

1 lb. 4–6 $12.50
2 lb. 8–10 $22.95
3 lb. 12–16 $30.95
4 lb. 16–24 $38.95



We offer 2 lb. and 4 lb. sampler cheesecakes.

The 2 lb. Sampler comes in four quarters and costs $25.50

  • 1 quarter Original
  • 1 quarter Marble
  • 1 quarter Raspberry Swirl
  • 1 quarter Strawberry Swirl

The 2 lb. Spring Sampler comes in four quarters and costs $27.25

  • 1 quarter Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup 
  • 1 quarter White Chocolate Raspberry Swirl 
  • 1 quarter Fudgy Brownie
  • 1 quarter Lemon

The 4 lb. Sampler has 16 individual slices and costs $41.95

  • 4 slices of Original
  • 4 slices of Marble
  • 2 slices of Raspberry Swirl
  • 2 slices of Chocolate Raspberry Swirl
  • 2 slices of Amaretto
  • 2 slices of Kahlua


Gluten Free:

A variety of our creamy cheesecake flavors made with NO CRUST at all. (Our cheesecakes contain no other wheat.) These cakes are carefully baked with those who have a gluten allergy in mind! No longer a need to go without, or have a second-rate dessert! Call ahead to order or see what we have available.

Gluten-Free Cheesecakes priced the same as Classic Cheesecakes.

Sugar Free:

Our rich and creamy cheesecakes contain very little sugar to start. For those who do not want any sugar – this one's for you. We use Xylitol (a sugar substitute – click for more info) to achieve the same Cheesy Eddie's quality and flavor, without the sugar. We are sure you will be amazed at the authentic taste. Call ahead to order or see what we have available.

Sugar Free Line Sizes, Servings, Prices:

1 lb. 4–6 $14.50
2 lb. 8–10 $26.50
3 lb. 12–16 $36.95
4 lb. 16–24 $45.95