Party Trays, Tarts and Cookies

NEW!! Apple Caramel Tart - Our buttery Shortbread Crust filled with homemade caramel and apples that have been sauteed in brandy and cinnamon.  Topped with streusel, and baked to perfection! 

Size       Servings              Price

8"         6-8 servings         $18.95

10"       10-12 servings      $28.95

Slice      Single                  $3.95

Muddy Bottom Tart – Always surprises! A made-from-scratch shortbread crust painted with chocolate, filled with nuts and homemade caramel, with a drizzle of chocolate. A scrumptiously versatile treat that is enjoyable with morning coffee or evening dessert with a scoop of ice cream!

8" 6–8 servings $17.95
10" 10–12 servings $27.95
Bars  Single

Dessert Trays

Cheesy Eddie's Dessert Trays come in all shapes and sizes.

Select any of the following. We suggest 2 per person.

  • Mini Cheesecake – Original, Chocolate, Key Lime, Raspberry
  • Mini Carrot Cake
  • Mini Peanut Butter Blossom
  • Peanut Butter Ganache Brownies
  • Mini Jillian's Delights
  • Cheesy Brownie
  • Fudgy Brownie
  • Muddy Bottom
  • Peanut Butter Ganache Brownie

These desserts can be boxed for display on your glassware or silver, or we can arrange them on a domed tray with a decorative ribbon.

Boxed: $2.50 per person.

Trayed: $2.80 per person. (Minimum: 10 persons.)

Jillian's Delights – Two chewy Oatmeal cookies, brought together with a layer of our famous cream cheese frosting! (A match made in heaven.)

Jack's -  Speaking of a match made in heaven... Get it?  Jacks-&-Jills...  These are two Chocolate Chip cookies with the cream cheese frosting in the middle!                                                                                                  Jack'sJacks & Jills

Size Pricing
Large (could serve 2!) $5.25
Small (just right for 1) $2.75
Mini (bite-sized!) $1.25


Brownies – The classic chocolate lover's dessert! At Cheesy Eddie's, brownies come in variety! Cheesy Brownies are thick chocolate brownies with a layer of cheesecake over the top. Fudgy Brownies are strictly chocolate, thick and chewy.  They are sold individually for $1.65 or in a ½ sheet for $37.50

Cookies – Baked with only butter, our cookies remind you of grandma's house! Our kitchen is a No Shortening Zone! Oversized Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Double Chip, Chewy Oatmeal, and Oatmeal Raisin. $1.75 each.

Lemon Bars – Not too tart and not too sweet, this lemon filled treat is a wonderful balance of both. $1.65 each.

Peanut Butter Blossom – A Chocolate cookie crumb crust with peanut butter and cream cheese mousse. $4.95 each.

Chocolate Ganache Brownie - Our fudgy brownie with a layer of ganache and a layer of Peanut Butter Cream Cheese frosting $3.25

Cheesecake Blossoms - Our rich creamy cheesecake in the shape of a cupcake.  Available in 3 different flavors, (Original Vanilla, Chocolate, & Key Lime). $4.95

Russian Tea Cakes – A dainty delight. Shortbread with nuts, rolled in confectioner's sugar.  $.65 ea